When my sister Jill shared her Apple Pie Cookies recipe with me, I didn’t just bake them—I brought them to all three Thanksgiving celebrations this weekend. Each time, these little bites of apple pie magic had everyone talking. They taste just like the real thing, but in a perfect, shareable cookie form. It’s moments like these that remind me recipes aren’t just about taste—they’re about the joy and memories we create around the table.
2 hrs
Not Mentioned
10-12 mins
18-20 cookies
For the apple filling:
For the cinnamon cookie dough:
For the cinnamon sugar:
Apple Filling:
Cookie Dough:
Cinnamon Sugar:
Use Granny Smith, Braeburn, Fuji, Honeycrisp apples or something similar. Those apple varieties have the best flavor and hold their shape well after baking. Avoid soft flesh apples (like Red Delicious) - they break down into mush when heated!
How to Make Apple Pie Cookies